O1 visa

What is Expository?

Introduction

Before we begin, I must say this. I’ve missed the mark, I’ve fallen short.

Upon arriving in Tennessee, I laboriously examined over 20 churches before finding a church that was Reformed and practiced the discipline of expository teaching and preaching. That’s hard work, but it was all necessary. This is a bad testimony of the “Bible Belt” (word used loosely). Sadly, Biblical expository preaching is becoming less popular. According to the internet, Christians are hungry for expository preaching.

There are various methods of studying, preaching, or teaching. For example, topical studies. But with topical studies there’s a greater risk in erroring with an eisegesis. And so, here we are, the next addition to my ‘What Is’ series.

As you’ll see later, one notable scholar said of expository preaching. “So we share the conviction that faithful exposition of Scripture is not only the bread and butter of pastoral preaching in the local church, but it’s actually the very essence of all real preaching.” Or, as another scholar below said, “All true preaching is expository preaching, and that preaching which is not expository is not preaching.” If you want to attribute these quotes to their author, you’ll need to finish reading. Unless you cheat by pressing Ctrl + F on your keyboard.

Whether we examine the word expository, exposition, or an expositor, as an adjective, a verb, or a noun, my definition below remains the same.

What is Expository?

In summary, gleaning from my study, the definition of expository (or an expositor) is this.

An expository (or expositional) teaching means to expose and explain the text. It’s an exposé of the Scriptures. It means to be more exact and more systematic with the Word of God. It’s a comprehensive analysis with interpretational fidelity of what God is saying, not what we’re saying. There’s an emphasis on a sound exegesis of the Scriptures, rather than on the preacher’s own words, opinions, or what he’s trying to say. An exposition demonstrates proper hermeneutics (contextual, grammatical & historical) and the whole counsel of God. It is a discipline which requires laboring in an in-depth study of the Scriptures, and much time in sermon preparation. An exposition preaches distinctly from the Word of God, book by book, chapter by chapter, verse by verse. It progresses through the Scriptures, giving an explanation and application. And when not sure, as one scholar said, if we error, then we must “err on the side of interpretive restraint rather than interpretive excess.”

Below are a few verses to consider.

“So they read in the book in the law of God distinctly, and gave the sense, and caused them to understand the reading.” – Nehemiah 8:8

“Then the Spirit said unto Philip, Go near, and join thyself to this chariot. And Philip ran thither to him, and heard him read the prophet Esaias, and said, Understandest thou what thou readest? And he said, How can I, except some man should guide me? And he desired Philip that he would come up and sit with him.” – Acts 8:29-31

“Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.” – 2 Timothy 2:15

What an expositor (or exposition) is not

Having said that, in short, below is what an expositor (or exposition) is not.

It does not skip or gloss over controversial verses, doctrine, or words just because it might offend someone. Reading all the Scriptures, but merely talking about the Bible, is not an expository teaching. Nor is telling stories.

Expository sermons are not about the preacher, you, or me. They are all about Him and whom or what He’s talking about in His Scriptures. In other words, keeping it vertical, rather than the horizontal distractions from the Lord.

An expository teaching is not making your sermon match the title you gave it. Though I haven’t always, I prefer to call a sermon by the chapter and verse, e.g., “Today’s sermon will be an exposition of Genesis 1:1-10,” and so on.

OK, I have defined the word expository, and what it is not. So you could stop right here. Or, if you choose to dive deeper for a more comprehensive definition of expository, then go with me further.

The following is from just a few of the many resources I’ve read on this subject.

From Empty Admiration: Robert Lewis Dabney’s Expository Homiletic

“Over against this broad understanding of exposition, Dabney also wrote in Sacred Rhetoric about “expository sermons” and “expository preaching,” by which he meant something narrower. Dabney did not offer an explicit definition of expository preaching, but piecing together his understanding presents little difficulty. In an expository sermon, the Argument is comprised of an extended exposition that unfolds according to the versification of the text. Dabney wrote: “If the text contains a number of verses of Scripture, the whole of which are to be explained and applied in their connection, the discussion is called an ‘expository’ sermon.” An expository sermon represented “a continuous explication” of the text, presenting “a detailed examination of the verses,” and unfolded “as the phrases or commas of the text stand in the Scriptures.” Dabney therefore differentiated between an expository sermon and a sermon that was merely “expository of the Scriptures.” While the former offered an extended exposition that unfolded according to the versification of the text, the latter often yielded a sermon more akin to a topical lecture than a verse-by-verse unfolding of a passage of Scripture. Dabney nevertheless believed that either form could offer a “true exposition” of the text.

Dabney thus wrote of (1) the Exposition, which was a formal, structural sermon component, not unlike an Introduction or a Conclusion, of (2) exposition in general, which represented of any and all lines of evidence employed to establish that the biblical text contained the topic about which the preacher intended to preach, and of (3) expository preaching in particular, in which the Argument was comprised of an extended exposition that unfolded according to the versification of the text, and which often continued through a book of Scripture.

Dabney’s admiration for expository preaching as a category of sermon distinct from the topical form of his day drives the analysis that follows, and the remainder of this chapter therefore delves into Dabney’s Sacred Rhetoric and other writings in order to establish the features of his homiletical theory for consecutive expository preaching.”

Russell St. John, Empty Admiration: Robert Lewis Dabney’s Expository Homiletic (Eugene, Oregon: Pickwick Publications, 2020).

More from Empty Admiration

    “Good expository preaching is always permanently attractive, and always most important to those whom it is most important to attract. It meets the great appetite of the human mind—the desire to know; it instructs. No man who has any intelligent sensibility toward sacred things can fail to make the reflection that, if the Bible is our authoritative rule of faith, then it is a matter of transcendent, of infinite concern to him to get the right meaning of that book … Hence, he who proposes to open the meaning of the Scriptures meets the most serious desire of their religious nature. If this work is done successfully, without undo pedantry and prolixity, but with a plain and honest mastery of the task, which is obvious to the good sense of the hearer, if his judgment is convinced that the preacher has indeed given him the clue of correct understanding, nothing can be so attractive to him. He feels that this is precisely what he needed.”

Russell St. John, Empty Admiration: Robert Lewis Dabney’s Expository Homiletic (Eugene, Oregon: Pickwick Publications, 2020).

From Power in the Pulpit: How to Prepare and Deliver Expository Sermons

“This book is not about all things preaching. It’s unapologetically about expository preaching. When the biblical words above are brought together with the instructions about preaching found in the Bible, they can only lead to one conclusion: preaching today should be expository in nature. So we share the conviction that faithful exposition of Scripture is not only the bread and butter of pastoral preaching in the local church, but it’s actually the very essence of all real preaching. In describing the difference between a lecture and a sermon, Lloyd-Jones says that “a sermon does not start with a subject; a sermon should always be expository.” Stott agrees: “I cannot myself acquiesce in this relegation (sometimes even grudging) of expository preaching to one alternative among many. It is my contention that all true Christian preaching is expository preaching.

The resurgence of expository preaching, however, has subtly entertained a broader understanding of the practice that includes varying perspectives. Again, Allen helps us:


  Much that goes under the umbrella of exposition today is not really worthy of the name. While there are many books on the subject of preaching, those that promote an expository approach to preaching are few and far between. Of these, many treat the subject in more general and traditional ways.

So let’s make sure we’re using the same dictionary and not just the same words. Exposition obviously is built on the root verb “expose,” which means to lay open or uncover. When a preacher is doing exposition he is laying open what the Holy Spirit is saying in a given biblical text. So we can define expository preaching like this:

Def’ə-nish’ən

expository preaching n. The process of laying open the biblical text in such a way that the Holy Spirit’s intended meaning and accompanying power are brought to bear on the lives of contemporary listeners.

The above definition contains four key components that merit closer analysis—the subject of the biblical text, the process of laying open, the pursuit of the Spirit’s intended meaning, and the aim of bringing it to bear on contemporary listeners….”

Jerry Vines and Jim Shaddix, Power in the Pulpit: How to Prepare and Deliver Expository Sermons, Revised Edition (Moody Publisher, 2017), 30–31.

From “The Exposition of Scripture—a Teaching Ministry,” in Baker’s Dictionary of Practical Theology (more comprehensive & technical)

The Exposition of Scripture—a Teaching Ministry

“Ministers who take seriously the Scriptural injunction to “preach the word” (2 Tim. 4:2) and who recognize that there is an obligation concerning didache for all who, in their pulpit activities, would be faithful to the kerygma (cf. N. J. D. White’s treatment of 2 Timothy 4:2 in The Expositor’s Greek Testament), will find that expository preaching is by far the most appropriate method of sermonizing. In fact it could be said that it is the only kind of pulpit discourse which can truly be called preaching.

Traditionally, expository preaching has been thought of as one of the three ways to sermonize, to be distinguished from the topical and the textual approaches. Thus it has been conceived of almost exclusively in terms of homiletical structure. Whereas the preacher’s choice and the textual sermon deals with a single statement of the Scriptures, the expository sermon “comes mainly,” according to Blackwood in his Expository Preaching for Today, “from a Bible passage longer than two or three consecutive verses.” Blackwood’s definition is typical of those given by Broadus, Meyer, and other great expositors and authorities on homiletics of past generations.

Contemporary definitions of expository preaching, however, tend to be expressed in terms of sermon content. Miller, for example, in The Way to Biblical Preaching, insists that “truly biblical exposition is limited only by the broad principle that the substance of one’s preaching should be drawn from the Bible.” He defines expository preaching as “an act wherein the living truth of some portion of Holy Scripture, understood in the light of solid exegetical and historical study and made a living reality to the preacher by the Holy Spirit, comes alive to the hearer as he is confronted by God in Christ through the Holy Spirit in judgment and redemption.” On this premise he maintains that “all true preaching is expository preaching, and that preaching which is not expository is not preaching.”

It is impossible to argue successfully against Miller’s ideas at this point if one agrees with Ramm, in his Protestant Biblical Interpretation, that “the preacher is a minister of the Word of God. He is not a person who has a full and free right of sermonizing before a group of people. If he is a true minister of God, he is bound to the ministry of the Word of God.” Thus, by whatever procedures he may prepare and deliver his sermon, the truly Biblical preacher will be restricted to the expounding (i.e., the explanation and or interpretation) of God’s truth as inscripturated in some passage of the Bible. If he fails to be an expositor of God’s Word, he simply is not preaching. As Ramm reminds us, the preacher’s “fundamental task is not to be clever or sermonic or profound, but to minister the truth of God.” This requires that all sermons be expository, in the true sense of the term. Littorin sums it up well in his How to Preach the Word with Variety when he says that “only in exposition, well prepared and presented, can one sound the very voice of God in the ears and hearts of the people before him.”

Historically, expository preaching has its roots deeply embedded in the Judao-Christian tradition. As Glen points out in the 1959 Smyth Lectures which have been published as The Recovery of the Teaching Ministry, “the pulpit tradition inherited from the Protestant Reformation, and indirectly from the Jewish synagogue, demands that the pulpit assume a major responsibility for teaching.” The custom among the post-exilic Jews is described by Sherrill in The Rise of Christian Education: “As Hebrew became an unfamiliar language except to scholars, it was necessary to translate. One verse from the Torah, or as many as three verses from the prophets, would be read. Then the translator would render it, giving it to the people in their own tongue. He was not permitted to read his translation, but must give the sense in a free interpretation. It is easy to see how naturally this free translation with explanation would pass into the homily which is a more formal discourse based on portions of Scripture. It is not certain when this became a part of the service, but it was familiar in the time of Jesus. The detailed expounding of Scripture might last until late afternoon.” Thus the expository sermon, at least in embryonic form, was a familiar phenomenon among the people of God by the time the New Testament age began.

Our Lord is called by F. B. Meyer, in his Expository Preaching, “the Prince of Expositors.” Of him Luke says that “beginning at Moses and all the prophets, he expounded (diermeneuen—explained) unto them all the scriptures the things concerning himself” (Luke 24:27). Although Luke is no more explicit than this, this brief comment does indicate Christ’s expository treatment of the Old Testament.

Luke describes the Apostle Paul’s ministry in similar language. When, during his first imprisonment in Rome, the leaders of the Jewish community visited him, to them “he expounded (ektitheto—unloosed or explained) and testified the kingdom of God, persuading them concerning Jesus, both out of the law of Moses, and out of the prophets” (Acts 28:23). He too preached expositorily. And this appears to be characteristic of the New Testament throughout. “It is instructive,” says Meyer, “how much of the New Testament is expository of the Old.”

This apostolic practice of expounding the Scriptures continued during the early centuries of the church’s history. But, when the Scriptures were supplanted by religious ceremony and the clergy became priests rather than preachers of God’s Word, a long hiatus developed in the history of expository preaching. This was not broken until the eruption of the Protestant Reformation and the rediscovery of the principle of sola Scriptura. An important consequence of this was the replacement of the mass by the preaching of the Word of God. Caemmerer reminds us that both of the great Reformers “Martin Luther and John Calvin presented expositions of the entire Bible.” The reappearance of expository preaching and the success of the Reformation are far from being merely coincidental.

In the English speaking world the expository sermon is for the most part a heritage from the Scottish Presbyterians and the English Free Churchmen (cf. F. R. Webber’s History of Preaching in Britain and America, Parts One, Two, and Three). Out of this tradition came such pulpit luminaries as Lawson, Brown, Eadie, Maclaren, and G. Campbell Morgan—expositors all. Archibald Alexander, Princeton Seminary’s first professor, was from a Scottish background and both by his teaching and example introduced expository preaching to the United States in the first part of the nineteenth century. G. Campbell Morgan, on his frequent visits to America, was perhaps the most potent single influence in demonstrating the advantages of the exposition of the Scriptures to congregations in this country.

The construction of an expository sermon depends on these three essential steps: the selection of the Scriptural passage to be expounded, the exegesis of the text, and the application of the truth derived therefrom to the contemporary situation. The homiletical structure is comparatively irrelevant, as long as it is in accord with sound communication theory.

The choosing of the particular Biblical excerpt to be expounded is crucial. The wisest choice results from a knowledge of the will of God and an understanding of the needs of one’s congregation. Prayerful waiting upon the Spirit for guidance and an intelligent insight into the needs of the audience combine to lead the preacher to the phrase, verse, paragraph, chapter, or book from which, in a single sermon or in a protracted series, he will confront his hearers with the living Word of God. Apart from these, the minister may bring the wrong message in that it will be inappropriate to the particular situation faced at the existential moment of his preaching the sermon.

Second, and equally important, is the exegesis of the text. Littorin is right when he insists that “exegesis is always, without variation, the parent of exposition.” The only legitimate handling of the Scriptures is to lead out (literal meaning of “to exegete”) that, and only that, which God has written in.

At all costs eisegesis, rightly called by Cleland in his Preaching to be Understood a “homiletical sin,” is to be avoided. By means of this “leading into” the passage ideas not present, the text, to use Cleland’s figure, “becomes a magician’s hat. The sermonic rabbit which the preacher pulls from the hat was not originally in the hat. He found the rabbit in the hat because he put it there.” Congregations may be amused by the thaumaturgic appearances of these sermonic rabbits, but such homiletical legerdemain is a fraud, unworthy of the prophet who must, if he is to be faithful to his God-given assignment, preface his message with the “Thus saith the Lord.” Exegesis is the only honest way to deal with the Scriptures. No one is exempt from its demands. Every preacher must ask the same question which John Brown, a pulpit craftsman of the last century, asked himself when an idea occurred to him as he examined his text: “This is true and it is important, but is it the truth taught in this text?” If it is not in the text, it cannot be in a sermon which professes to be an exposition of the text.

For an explication of the hermeneutical rules of grammatico-historical exegesis, the reader is referred to such sources as Ramm’s Protestant Biblical Interpretation and Mickelsen’s Interpreting the Bible. Ramm’s work also includes a four-page list of books which he considers a “minimum Bibliography for exegetical work.” To ascertain what the writer of a Biblical statement was saying to his contemporaries and to state those same ideas in today’s idiom involve the exegete in hard work. This is why preachers have studies in their home or at their churches. Nothing less than the sound, honest exegetical treatment of the passage will suffice.

Yet, an expository sermon cannot be a mere recital of the findings of study. It is more than a commentary; it is a sermon. Ramm correctly says that one of the dangers of exegesis is that “it is likely to stop with exegesis and not press on to the feeding ministry of the Word of God. It should result in a truly Biblical teaching and preaching ministry in which relevant application is made to listeners.” The truth of God in the passage being expounded must be made contemporary in the fullest sense. It must be made relevant to the particular congregation to which it is delivered at the particular moment in which it is being heard. Members of the audience, after having listened to an expository sermon, must be able to answer not only the question, “What does God say in this text?” but “What does God say to me in this text?”

Thus a sermon appropriate for yesterday may not be germane today. The same sermon cannot be preached in the chapel services of both a college and a penitentiary. The sermon delivered to an adult congregation will differ greatly from the message given at a junior church service. To be sure, the truth of God is forever settled in the heavens. But its application must of necessity differ from audience to audience.

The advantages of expository preaching are numerous. Some of these accrue to the benefit of the preacher himself. As Broadus, in his monumental Treatise on the Preparation and Delivery of Sermons says, “It is one of the benefits of expository preaching that it compels the preacher to study.” It demands on the preacher’s part a rigorous exploration of the Scriptures in depth. Thus he becomes increasingly better acquainted with the truth of God. The exegesis which exposition requires is an excellent discipline by which he becomes ever more knowledgeable in the area of his distinguishing specialty—i.e., God’s special revelation of Christ in the written Word.

Along the same line, expository preaching spares the preacher from yielding to the besetting ministerial sin of “riding hobbies” in the pulpit. As F. B. Meyer has said, “No other style of preaching can so completely guarantee immunity from an indulgence in special crochets and fads.” It is normal for each pastor to have his own personal preferences for certain sermonic themes. His natural inclinations, however, will often lead him to an overemphasis of his favorite subjects. The best safeguard against falling prey to his proclivity is systematic exposition. In this way a preacher is more apt to communicate the whole council of God.

The principal gain, however, will be realized by the congregation. “Expository preaching,” as Littorin says, “is the door to an educated constituency.” Members of churches where the exposition of the Scriptures is the regular practice will be adequately grounded in that which is Christianity rightly so called. They will learn, intellectually and experientially, true Christian doctrine.

Teaching is the only effective antidote to ignorance. And that an alarming illiteracy of distinctive Christian belief exists in the typical Protestant church can be well documented. Mullen, in his Renewal of the Ministry, claims that “Never before in our church history have so many enrolled church members known so little about the Bible.” Evangelicals must especially beware of the temptation to exempt their own constituencies from this diagnosis of doctrinal illiteracy, particularly if the basis for doing so is the ability of their church members to recite Bible verses or to repeat cliches which have an orthodox sound. If the church’s aim for the occupant of the pew is an intelligent understanding of the faith and a demonstration in life of Biblical principles, it must be conceded that ignorance abounds even in the most orthodox churches.

Miller correctly attributes this ignorance to a departure in the American pulpit from the centrality of Biblical preaching. “A famine is abroad,” he laments, “ ‘not a famine of bread, not a thirst for water, but of hearing the words of the Lord’ (Amos 8:11).” The absence of truly expository preaching is a major contributing cause of the prevailing Biblical deficiency among lay people which threatens the health of the church.

In the interest of providing spiritual nurture for God’s growing children, the diet must be enriched. Church members must be fed both the “milk” and the “meat” of revealed truth. Blackwood suggests that too often “we underestimate the capacity of God’s people to digest sermonic food.” The minimum weekly requirements of all Christians for spiritual nutriment call for regular expository preaching.

There are also certain pitfalls which must be avoided by the expositor. One of the most dangerous of these is a lack of unity and progress in the exposition of the message. Blackwood reminds us that “Critics of preaching say that the average expository sermon has neither beginning, middle, nor end. Like a ball of twine, it simply unwinds.” This criticism usually applies to so-called expository sermons which are in reality verse-by-verse running commentaries. It is the lazy man’s caricature of exposition.

The remedy for this is twofold. First, a goal for the sermon must be made explicit in the thinking of the sermon builder. No man ever reached his destination without knowing what it was. Before constructing the message the preacher must know what he wants to accomplish. Second, a well-organized outline must be prepared. At times the outline may appear in the very structure of the passage. More frequently, however, it will be the responsibility of the preacher to organize the divinely revealed truths in a logical and orderly arrangement. Either way, an outline is essential for unity and progression.

Another snare to be avoided by the minister who would preach expositorily—and by all preachers who would teach through their sermons—is the assumption that people learn merely by hearing the truth articulated. Many specialists in learning theory have concluded that the lecture method is one of the poorest techniques for teaching. Yet practically all preaching is lecturing. How many preachers, nevertheless, ignoring the basic principles of learning process, persist in soliloquizing in the pulpit before a passive audience. It should be no surprise that so little of what is said is really learned.

Every preacher who would teach through sermons must understand how people learn. It cannot be said that one has taught unless someone has learned. And God has so constructed men, and hereditary and environmental factors have so influenced the organism that he has designed, that human beings tend to learn in certain ways which the educational psychologists, by God’s common grace, have discovered. These must be utilized, if a congregation is to learn from the preacher.

One such principle which cannot be overlooked is that of dialog between teacher and learner. In other words, there must be interchange between pulpit and pew. Passivity in the congregation inhibits real learning. Yet how can there be dialog between a preacher who speaks uninterruptedly for a half-hour and his listeners who sit in reverential silence before him? The answer is that each member of the congregation must be provoked to think. His mind must be active, even though his body is inactive. There can be dialog between pulpit and pew, even though the responses from the congregation are not expressed audibly. Indeed, there must be such dialog for learning to take place.

It is impossible here to present an adequate treatment of the important aspects of learning theory. The reader is referred to the Bibliography in the author’s Introduction to Evangelical Christian Education. Let every pulpit-teacher familiarize himself with the psychology of learning.

Sermons with cognitive content, as contrasted to messages which can only excite the emotions or entertain an audience, are essential to the maintenance of the faith as well as to the building of the church. There can be no better content in sermons than the Word of God. Expository preaching is the means by which that Word is taught from the pulpit. Consequently, as Mickelsen says, “The crucial question to ask oneself at the close of every sermon is: did the word (the proclaimed truth of God) become alive to me and to my hearers?” The preacher who can answer this question in the affirmative has really preached.”

J. Edward Hakes, “The Exposition of Scripture—a Teaching Ministry,” in Baker’s Dictionary of Practical Theology, ed. Ralph G. Turnbull (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Book House, 1967), 416–21.

This post is part of a What Is series I’m working on. I hope it was helpful. I encourage you to study this word for yourself. Together, let’s Make Expository Great Again.

Add a Comment